Follow
Share
Read More
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
1 2 3 4 5
Didn't know this was turning into the Huffington Post
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Thanks for opening up this discussion, "deleteaccount" - I'm sure this affects the majority of our seniors, who grew up with mainstream media, most of which are motivated by high ratings and profitability. Rape, violence, murder, slander, gossip, family feuds, legal wranglings, injustice, war, animal cruelty, parental neglect, environmental disasters... it's a steady diet of the worst possible news from around the globe.

My parents read a daily newspaper that spews bad news, and they keep the television on to watch an all-news/all-day station that just reiterates and vomits the worst stories of the day ad nauseum. My father rants about the state of the world and my mother frets endlessly about all the things that might befall her grandchildren. Both have dementia - they might forget the stories, but they certainly remember the feelings the stories stir up inside them.

I have been trying to wean them off their "bad news" addiction by bringing in positive stories about heroes and compassion, by putting some of the stories in perspective (they live in a quiet neighbourhood where even the cats and dogs are bored), and by reminding them that, at any given moment, we have SO MUCH to be grateful for.

It's a cultural sickness, our addiction to other people's dramas, and the media has accelerated its stronghold on audiences. It's impossible for most of us to NOT watch a train wreck, but watching it all day and every day creates links in our brains and fears and feelings that aren't even real. As Roosevelt noted, the only thing we have to fear is fear itself.

I have studied Buddhist philosophy extensively, and went for a few months without any input from any news sources. It was blissful, and my life didn't change a whit. As I understand it, life is all about balance. Achieving that right balance of negative and positive dramas is the solution. How to do that in a capitalistic degenerative news environment is the real question!
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I think ALL the political ridiculous comments on here SHOULD BE DELETED by whomever runs this site. Talk about biased and mean! We don't all share your political views and I didn't think this was a political forum, so please rant elsewhere ! And to answer the question, yes, my mom constantly watches the news because she thinks this younger generation is spoiled, takes our freedoms for granted and so hers must remain vigilant!
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Good for her, Jeanie. And she's not wrong, is she? Long may her watchdog's teeth stay sharp.

I think the serious point about the original thread, though, is that as perception changes then older people with dementia can become very distressed by what they see, out of normal proportion for them. Then you're left with the choice of either censoring their viewing, or allowing them to be exposed to often lurid reporting - think of some of the shockers around over the last few months, which certainly freak me out and I like to think of myself as reasonably philosophical. I don't think there is an ideal answer, sadly.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Delete apart from my snide comments earlier I need you to know this. I have had to stop Mum watching any programmes that relate to violence of any sort. By violence I refer to anything that is gratuitously violent. I also don't let her watch the main news because that too can be a little graphic. However she does watch local news because that 'tends' to be more forthcoming with better news....the softer touch you might say.

I think once dementia sets in there is a huge difficulty for some people in differentiating between fact and fiction and also between news in general and reality to them.

Hence my mother thinking Donald Trump was George Patten (because they do look similar) and because she misheard Trump (which is not a word over here except to be a child's word for breaking wind) and because she saw Sarah Palin she heard strumpet which is something she recognises. Now she has a set of pseudo facts and has merged them with the George Patten she does remember and of course George Patten wouldn't have married a strumpet.

Hence my mother believing that NCIS is real and although she wanted to watch it I refused to let her watch band of brothers which is a war based series but some of the shots are sometimes so horrific and graphic she would have believed that was happening today in this city and not only been depressed but frightened too.

Mum would not be able to differentiate for example between the reality of 911 and the fictional towering inferno. Her reference points for reality were shaped long before special effects which just adds to the complexity of the problem

The sad thing is we can only guess what is going on in their minds and that is so frustrating.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

habits are best changed when replaced with something desirable. every saturday at breakfast… and i mean EVERY saturday, we watched a hilarious movie with my mom. we all knew every line and scene by heart and that's what made it all the funnier.

'It's a Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World' (1963) With Spencer Tracy, Milton Berle, Ethel Merman, Mickey Rooney, to only name a few. The dying words of a thief spark a madcap cross-country rush to find some treasure. makes you cry funny. and of mom's generation.

also, dvd boxed sets of I Love Lucy, The Dick Van Dyke Show, The Carol Burnett Show, The Bennie Hill Show (racey british… but we love it) etc. we have a regular schedule for each show everyday.

as folks are going to digital media, i find them from friends, craiglist, amazon & ebay for pretty cheap. somehow whipping out a DVD makes it more of an occasion for my mom then just downloading it. also, it's something tangible she can touch so it cues her better and seeing the DVDs on the shelf gives her something to look forward to.

you may not be able to make the news go away completely, but i believe balancing it out with something funny is a great place to start and a win-win… if only for an hour. even one belly laugh a day is good medicine, yes?

also, beautiful ester williams movies and musicals of her era are always uplifting.

you are an awesome daughter/son!!! hugs to you :)

p.s. america's funniest home videos NEVER misses the mark with mom… though it disgusted my aunt, so we had to sneak it in around her… lol.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

p.p.s. by the way, we call the above strategy "OPERATION: KILL THE FOX". take that fox network… :)
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

p.p.p.s. hey, ya'll… on both sides. this isn't about political views here, it is about gratuitous, unrelenting, churning of bad news & negativity that is just TOO MUCH on all media outlets on both sides these days.

if we keep our focus on THAT, there is room for all of us to weigh in on this. i didn't mean to single FOX out for any reason other than my folks consumed nothing but FOX and cop shows. whether i like something or not, i fully support everyone watching what they want. it the Right of us all, and that is the other important thing.

hugs all around!
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

My mother not only thought some fictional shows fiction were real, but that she knew the victims! (Both in fiction and on the news.) I just distracted her with puzzles and PBS. Her Alzheimers has sufficiently advanced that now I have her watch PBSkids and the Saturday morning nature shows on one of the regular broadcast stations. Her favorites are Wild Kratts and Curious George.

She also enjoys her exercises - which, given that she is wheelchair bound and very stiff are very simple. But perhaps it is the interaction she relishes.

As for voting: vote for Bernie! Or Jill Stein, ;)
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

I really feel bad for my mother because she is so scared.I would hate to live like that feeling that the end of the USA is near
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

My first thought is if she is on depression meds?
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

You don't say if sje has Dementia. My Mom no longer knows how to use the remote. I don't allow news or shows like Emergency. She believes what is on the TV is happening in the house and gets upset.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Jeaniepo and careinhome, I'm with you both. I had to wade through so much political blather that I'm sure I missed some relevant comments. (I'll keep my mouth shut about what I think of both sides in the Presidential Reality Show....)

Are you still with us, deleteaccount? One thing that would be helpful to know is just how mentally impaired your mother is. How tuned in is she to the reality she is watching? (Yes, I know that the mainstream media is pathetically out of touch with actual reality.) If you disabled the television and substituted old movies and comedy, would she catch on? (Fred Astaire! Bob Hope & Bing Crosby! Charlie Chan mysteries! Gilligan's Island reruns! etc.)

Others have mentioned tuning in to cooking shows, game shows, nature shows and situation comedies. All these are great ideas if she is not fixated on watching the news and constantly channel surfing as soon as your back is turned.

My mother watched primarily game shows, sitcoms and the news---but her hearing was so bad she couldn't really hear what they were saying! It was all just visuals and the more action the better. Eventually her dementia progressed to the point where she now has no more interest in TV, newspapers or magazines and just wants to be in the same room other people are in.

When I am the only one around, it's useless to try and get anything done on my computer (still designing posters and stuff, although retired), so I just bring my laptop to her and show her family videos or fun video shorts I find online, or I go through family albums with her and pick her brain for stories of her girlhood.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

During my mother's stays in 2 nursing rehab facilities, I tried every way to get them to keep the TV on reasonable channels. But I would walk in and my mother would be terrified that the apocalypse had come and that the world was burning outside her window because of what was playing on the TV. Or she'd be sobbing over a lost child on Nancy Grace. I put up LARGE SIGNS, I posted the times and channels of her favorite safe programs. But even if I could get ONE staff member to put the TV on PBS for "nature" or Keeping Up Appearances, then after that could be a documentary on war, or a murder mystery, which she would think was real and happening right now. The same for the Turner Classic Movies. A tap-dance film, then a war movie. She couldn't make sense of the movie, she'd just enjoy the musical, then be full of anxiety over the war movie. I tried programming a CD player for music to play for her. I don't know why nursing facilities aren't more cognizant of that. There was no way to block channels. There was no way she could be happy with that barrage of violent images coming at her, many times a day, whenever it was on. Even a sitcom, has quick-flashed previews for the murder show to follow, usually a body lying in a pool of blood -- distasteful to me knowing it's fake, but horrific to her thinking it's real. I was so glad to get her home.
Storyteller tapes -- she could listen and enjoy and process those, really understand them and laugh in the right places -- when she couldn't process books on tape. Donald Davis, Jim Weiss. Jonatha and Harold Wright. I would leave a CD playing on continuous play with headphones plugged in. All she had to do was put the headphones on to hear it. (She couldn't press the play button).
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

My best advice is to get a multi-disk DVD changer. Five disk changers are about $50. (then from there, they go up to very pricey.) and a multi-disk audio CD changer. Storyteller tapes are wonderful. You can also make playlists on YouTube. that will run several hours. How about Netflix -- an old TV series on Netflix will just scroll through to the next one.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

The fact that we even have the freedom to comment, suggest, poke fun at, agree, disagree, or seriously critique our politicians is wonderful. At least one Canadian, the British, and I'm sure others who haven't mentioned where they are from are interested in today's politicians.
Trump has made his place in American political history. He grabbed the attention of people across very diverse backgrounds. Rather than bringing the groups together, he is pitting one against the other. Our elderly can't begin to think or process anything positive. It offers no hope, no solutions, no freedoms. This negativity really conflicts with their values so must be quite distressing.
I think deleteaccount's question is really not just about the elderly. Baby Boomers are marching down this treacherous path. Their kids and grandkids must deal with the social and economic implications of dementia among other ailments.
I think the saving grace (not Nancy Grace) in earlier years was having only 3 channels to choose from. Topics were timely and relevant. Today's connected world makes it desirable to have many more choices for TV today. We have to learn when enough is enough and remove the remote.

In thinking about Jeaniego's idea of deleting the input from others it reminded me of the following:
It's the online users who forced the mainstream establishment to take seriously people's comments. Those were originally people who mostly had no access to the mainstream. Now the major media, manufacturers, businesses, law enforcement and national security rely on social websites to achieve their missions. So we should never delete any sites and conversations such as this. Maybe someday it will sink in - among politicians who have not yet been diagnosed with dementia.
.
When bad news prevailed in earlier years, anyone interested in more knowledge out came the newspaper and magazines. It was an alternative way to inform, educate, and then take a break from the horrible realities. Not so today - just all the horrible stuff flows into the living room like a backed up sewer main.
Mom liked to watch the old movie channels. Dad would sometimes flip it back to the all sports channels which bored my mom. That forced her to get up and take a break from the TV. Later they both became entranced with FOX news. After Dad died she became more attached to the remote and FOX. I cringed at some of the stuff she was talking about as it was negative.
But she got to see a little of Trump and Palin. She would get worked up about various characters - Trump, Palin, Pelosi, and others. When our elders can no longer process the world or work to improve life, it can become cruel in my opinion.
Mom talked about politicians every election cycle. Elections were serious business for her generation. I am glad she died before the media really got any more immersed in every tidbit of bad news it could muster up.
I think it's good deleteaccount asked the question!
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Jeaniepo, I see your viewpoint, but I also think that the issue of negative news is at the heart of the OP's query, and that the political comments may become a bit frivolous, but perhaps that's our own way of putting distance between real news and them, and of confirming to ourselves that most of the political tv isn't worth watching. We're just having a few "pokes" at people who VOLUNTARILY put themselves in channels of mass communication.

We too need to justify to ourselves what we're watching, even though we may not realize it, such as that the negative activities, especially that now of the massive devastation and suffering caused by Winter Storm Jonas, is somehow not going to happen to us.

Occasionally I've asked people about their free use of social media which commoditizes and sells personal information, about the liberal posting and sharing of personal information, of lack of concerns for their own privacy. I get different responses from whose who grew up with these activities vs. those my age, and for me who's worked in law and been concerned about massive violations of individual rights. The younger people are acclimated to privacy invasion - they grew up with it. People my age didn't, and some of us find it egregiously offensive.

I think it's also important to remember that so many of the people who are older and are watching tv as a pastime are also limited in mobility and are more concerned about that than people of a younger age. If I was 80 or 90+ and living in NJ, I'd be terrified of being without power in a flooded area in frigid weather. At least we who can move around. can get in a boat or perhaps be rescued, but if your mobility is limited, what are your options?

I don't claim to have professional psychological insight, but there have been times when I've been less mobile because of various injuries, and I find myself trending toward preoccupation with negative events so that I can plan alternatives in the event they happen to me.

Since my father's on oxygen which goes with us everywhere, I spend more time thinking about how to keep backup batteries warm in the car while we're at a medical appointment, how to haul the oxygen concentrator to the buildings when no one has snowed off walks and how to keep from falling myself....these seem like little things but could become major issues.

So I see how someone can fall into an obsession with negativity - what we don't know is whether or not these elder folks are trying to find ways to cope with it and think how they would handle the situation if it occurred, or even if the events are so terrifying that elders are so frightened they can't turn off the tv because they're hoping that some resolution will arise which would reverse the fear and anxiety they experience.


SingingWay makes a good point about the proliferation of garbage programs on tv. They're on everywhere - even in medical offices, and worse yet, in the radiological waiting room at our hospital! This aggravates me to no end. I've put in ear plugs to block out all those inane talk shows and soap operas.

But the assumption is made by someone - office staff? - that patients apparently are interested in this garbage. I've been tempted to bring a portable CD and play classical music in the waiting rooms.

Houseplant, your observations are insightful, highly relevant, and very important to this discussion, especially the societal changes that wrought the issues about which we're writing, and the insight into elders who can no longer process issues.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Just a comment about Houseplant's observation that elections used to be serious - now some aspects of elections trend toward being a fiasco, or even comical. Others are just plain disgusting with name calling, racial slurs, and offensive comments. Yet older people may still believe they're serious.

If I thought the worlds of Palin and Trump prevailed, I'd be depressed too.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Comical? If only. I've stopped waiting agog to hear the latest and am now averting my eyes.

Hey! - this is your election, it's not for outsiders to back a candidate. But it is also the world's business, it does matter to everyone, and in that sense there is an additional responsibility for American voters. That's what comes of being the last superpower standing.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I would politely disagree and feel that "outsiders" taking positions on candidates is critical. Can you imagine if Angela Merkel had to work with Palin or Trump? (I almost couldn't type this - my fingers rebelled!)

Remember the great relationship that Thatcher and Reagan had (not that I necessarily agreed with their politics)? Bush and Blair? Bush Sr. when he put together the coalition to challenge Iraq for Kuwait's "liberation?"

Can you imagine either of the two comic candidates attempting to create such a coalition?

The US government, for better or worse, does still believe it has the right to take the superpower role, and as such, needs to have a leader who understands diplomacy, international politics, foreign relations....something lacking by many of the candidates.

I think all the countries with which we have relationships have an interest in our elections, as do the Chinese, for their own reasons.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

And you're right - I stand corrected. It's not comical any more; it's an embarrassment.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

While we may have made fun of Palin and Trump as 'outsiders' I think perhaps you need to know what WE see over here in the UK. We aren't talking politics either this is about the people themselves and what they have said not about their parties. When Sarah Palin announces things that are simply untrue like the space race bankrupting Russia, or that the US should base its laws on the founding fathers notions of the biblical and Christian values when there is no mention of Christian Jesus or even God in the original documents shows a fundamental flaws in the person. When she doesn't know that pledge of allegiance came 100 years after the founding fathers then there is an issue. What is more if you put yourself out there you will get criticised.

When Trump inflates racial hatred by calling Mexican immigrants rapists, drug runners and criminals that is really worrying for foreign nationals. When he denigrates gay rights and same sex marriage yet he himself was married three times, when he says he will be the 'jobs' president yet has owned 4 bankrupt companies I as a brit have to say ....erm really this man is suitable as a candidate for ANY party? Not in my book he isn't. Anyone who is thoughtless enough to criticise the black poor on the very day 9 African Americans were shot to death probably by a white supremacist in a church has no understanding of appropriate comments to make in his own country let alone on a world stage. Even a Saudi prince has stood up and said he is a disgrace following his comments on Muslims.

And that is why I feel I had the right to comment - not political but personal not the party, but the man (and the woman)
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I can see why an elder who can possibly no longer link all the dots together would become worried.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I gather Mr Putin admires Mr Trump's undoubtedly successful track record. Don't know if that will alter anyone's mind..?

Angela Merkel has already had to deal with Yannis Varoufakis - the Finance Minister with the motor bike and the leather jacket and the red hot looks and hot red politics - and Silvio Berlusconi, who actually, on reflection, makes Donald Trump's personality look positively priest-like. So I feel sure she will cope.

If only the good were clever,
And if only the clever were good,
The world would be better than ever
We possibly thought it could.

OHMYGOD Donald Trump and Jeremy Corbyn on the phone about Da'esh..!!!! Oh all right I give in - I am now cackling hysterically. Jude will know what I mean, though she may not be laughing much - for American readers, Jeremy Corbyn is the newly(ish) elected Leader of Her Majesty's Loyal(ish, in his case) Opposition, and therefore to be taken seriously as the UK's potential next Prime Minister. Trust me, that's all you want to know.

What a shame that Hugo Chavez is no longer with us. International diplomacy could have had a real purple patch.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Sarah Palin is at least good for selling shimmering jackets.
Trump not even for hair restoration.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Any adults actually want to answer the question?
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Careinhome: Garden Artist, Countrymouse, Jude, and Veronica have all commented on this page and are actually adults. Some of the best AC has. That's the best we've got, our A-team, or part of them at least.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

They are a clown show just like the last 8 years of Obama.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

What was the question? Oh yeah, how wean people off saddening news because they think it's real and so become distressed.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Comments are essential at the grass roots level, which gives leaders a little breathing room. (They can better stifle themselves since the people are poking fun and asking questions). Laughter is good therapy - and it usually doesn't cost much do a skit or play around those who deserve such attention. I'm glad the rest of the world is pointing out Trump's and Palin's behaviors.
Trump should be paying attention to what men are saying. When men laugh and criticize him, it bumps it to another level - especially if those men are in positions of power. He just doesn't get it.
I think the much much older American women don't process the Clilnton situation as well as the younger women. She's a younger female and therefore unworthy of respect according to Trump. I heard one man say he's been a devout Republican but believes Trump is making Hillary the next president. Trump attacks Rubio and the children of politicians. He attacks female news reporters. The elderly haven't been attacked so much because they've not stood up to him. The fact that he has no empathy for anybody means he is available to be criticized by everybody, here and abroad. The elders are too worried to fight the good fight, so the younger must step in to get us going in a better direction. Trump is maybe too old to be president. Not in terms of numerical age, but mindset. My parents and their elderly friends all had more sense than Trump did at the time of their deaths. And they were older than Trump. My mom used to say people get what they deserve in old age. In the case of Donald it may just be a dump.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

1 2 3 4 5
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter