Follow
Share

I would like to know if anyone out there is in a legal battle with siblings over money they stole from an elderly parent (suffering from dementia). Everyone tells you to take them to court but they don't realize the cost or the reality of the situation. I am discovering it myself but luckily, our lawyer is taking the case on a contingency basis. Short history, my mom was basically tricked out of every penny from mostly one sibling but the other was not innocent either. It happened over many years. There was even a report to DCF but that yielded pretty much nothing because my mom wasn't "homeless" (she is living with me) and at the time, still defended the siblings saying that they did whatever they did "for her own good."

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
I would like a consult with your lawyer. I am the only caregiver Mom with me 2 years now. I am not her POA, Or health Proxy nor does mom excess income come to us. I am her Payee so we have ssd and my job. There is excess Income from dad which has to go to pooled trust.  sibling has all excess going to her now because I am trying to put in objections to Probate she is sending us some of it. I need help yet we haven't got it Parents money is paying estate lawyer who only talks to sibling unless he is threatening me.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
ssnow04 Jul 2020
Hi,
I'm so sorry to hear of your situation. My lawyer is just for the county and state I live in. You can do a search for probate/guardianship lawyers in your county. I think the first thing they are going to suggest is guardianship. At that point you have more power health wise and financially, so they say. Your siblings using parents money to pay for lawyer is typical, it is lousy that they can do that. As POA, they have a fiduciary responsibility and are not working in your mom's best interest. Consult the lawyer and see if your mom could sign a new POA giving it to you. I'm throwing some suggestions that you can keep in mind. Even my situation looks like an easy one for courts but these lawyers can drag out even the clearest of cases involving breach of fiduciary responsibility. My siblings so far have used my mom's money to buy another house, a new car and top notch lawyers to fight back. It's criminal if you ask me.
Also one person on this forum suggested watching the Netflix series Dirty Money...the show on guardianship. It will teach you a lot too.
Best of luck and feel free to message me if you want.
(0)
Report
My husband has one sister that would have taken everything if she could have. She removed herself from the family for the most part 17 years ago when her sons were 10 & 12 and not long after mom had passed. Started harassing that when eldest brother passed, 3 months before mom, there should have been $ that was to go to “her” boys from his estate. Nothing about the 3 other nephews and not that we were looking for anything from his for our son.  Honestly once Dad got done with all his expenses and debt there was nothing left and Dad paid some things from his own pocket. She was constantly having Dad meet her somewhere so he could pay for something or give her $ to the point that he was letting the farm bills slide so he could help her. Mind you she had a very good job with the state that could well support her. She was the master of big showy purchases for her boys only to turn around and sell whatever it was for a fraction of what Dad paid for it. The 3 sibling that were left running the farm finally got Dad to create an LLC to protect the business and he was given a paycheck to do with as he pleased, if it went to her that was his decision. Once he passed the crazy really came out. Phone calls at all hours, late night drive-by honkings (she lived an hour away), phone calls where she disguised her voice and said she was an attorney. Claims are that the LLC is illegal that Dad never probated OB will or Mom’s will, that Dad’s will should prevail even if written prior to formation of LLC and she is owed 1/6 of the farm. Two other sibling have since passed and now youngest sibling and her husband are in charge. DH and I gave stated we have no claims on anything as he left the farm 30 years ago. She has made no claims against one sibling who passed as he was married and had a son of his own. The other sibling never married and she claims that the will that was filed is false because she was left nothing. Her sons are now grown and the youngest sees her for what she is and has not seen her in almost a year. The elder son still lives with her, refuses to move out and feels that he must support her. 

The family chose not the go after what she took from Dad and just move on so as not to upset Dad any further. Fortunately by the time he needed to move to a memory care and his funds were spent the 5 years had passed and he was beyond the lookback.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
ssnow04 Jul 2020
I'm sorry to hear that....it seems so typical. The siblings so often spend all the money so there is nothing left to fight for. We were lucky in that Medicaid does look at the fact that my mom's money was stolen and my mom was able to get it. Hopefully they might go after OS for it.
(1)
Report
I realized I have a very vivid memory of OB bragging that as the oldest son he would stand to inherit everything and we other sibs could 'buy him out' What? Are we living in ancient Biblical times? I'm sure he used this reasoning to justify the out and out THEFT.

After Mother moved to the apartment in YB's home, OB would show up a couple times a week and 'borrow' dad's very expensive tools which he would pawn. He also was receiving about $200 per visit in cash from mother. Once he told me (with a straight face) that his then-wife really wanted a bigger and better diamond in her engagement ring and mother was financing it.

You just cannot make this stuff up.

OB was in jail several times--failure to pay child support and child sexual abuse. Mother asked the rest of us sibs to make his bail and pay his back-child support.

We went to court and saw him get the sentencing he deserved and not one of us gave a dime towards his 'release'. I would buy him groceries for his kids, but I would not give him cash. More than once I caught him going through my house, looking for a very valuable Chinese vase that was left to ME. The thought of him tearing through my drawers looking for this vase made me sick. Dh threatened him with the beating of his life and that ended that---but honestly, just knowing he was out there was enough to make me super anxious. His death did bring a great sense of calm to the whole family.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
ssnow04 Jul 2020
Yea, I'm glad you do finally have calm in your family. I would guess the OB was a golden child? Maybe but either way, he did have some idea that your mom's money belonged to him...wherever he got that idea...who knows. As for my OS and OB, they just decided that they wanted their inheritance earlier in their life (my OS actually said that one day)...are you kidding me? Mom's money is hers until she passes and wills it to someone. That's how ridiculous this thing gets.
(2)
Report
oh damn. This is the worst. Yes, experience here. Let me say that the courts are not always reasonable in the way we see reason.

My brother was an issue, he was mentally ill with many weird requests and behaviors. He became more unhinged as he got older.

One surprise was that he had to be evicted from living with them. He refused to leave, even after assaulting my father. That seemed a no-brainer, right? My dad was 78. But still had to do eviction proceedings. The mediator finally settled it BUT my parents had to pay money to him to resettle (first and last, security deposit, etc). The mediator even got money for him since it was winter time and "cold". I was shocked because they were fixed income and it was a lot to spend to get rid of him.

He sued another time because my mother had, allegedly, promised him new dental implants. This was big money, and any such promise was more likely a discussion of what he could get done 'If he wanted'. Her paying never was the deal. But he sued her for the amount. He didn't win it all, but he got SOME. Yep, he didn't use it for teeth, of course. Drugs and beer.

The third time he sued I didn't even go because I was so upset. I heard he'd made a huge scene in court.

Basically, you can't assume a judge or mediator will rule in the interest of reason. If you can avoid legal issues completely, even by buying him off somehow, you may be better off. The legal fees are insane.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
ssnow04 Jul 2020
Thanks for your story...it is a doozy. Your brother sounds either mentally off or a major sense of entitlement. I am not really expecting to recoup anything money wise but I hope that a judge will see the evidence that my mom was systematically cheated out of every penny she had (originally around $300k) and at least take my mom's side. I'm sure OS has hidden away anything in bank accounts.
(1)
Report
This is truly sad, but I know a case of it as well. Son took thousands from his mother through whining, threats of self-harm, general manipulation, etc. It started off as what was loosely termed a series of "loans" but which were (for the most part) eventually "forgiven." I think he may have paid back some of it - and then I assume he realized he really didn't have to because it wasn't enforceable. Technically, mother gave the money willingly and I know she would never use force to get repaid. There likely was never a written loan agreement or anything like that anyway. I think "forgiving" the loans was Mom's way of dealing with the anxiety this caused her due to getting scammed by her son. She could then view herself as generous - rather than a victim. Thank goodness this did not interfere with the Medicaid 5 year lookback. We didn't seek legal action because I know she would never have gone along with it. Another family member demanded that we "advocate" for her, but how would we do that when she would be sitting in her wheelchair insisting the money was forgiven loans? Mother didn't want her baby in trouble and we felt she had the right to decide that. However, if it would have interfered with her Medicaid, we would likely have had to do something - but I'm not sure what. And, you probably guessed it, son still is not financially stable. It's been years. And he has little to do with his mother anymore.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
ssnow04 Jul 2020
Same with my OS and OB...they have nothing to do with mom anymore now that she is tapped out. It was all an act by my OS to look like she cares so much for mom....she cared so much about the money, not mom. It does sound like in your circumstance, it doesn't do any good for legal action as your brother may be judgement proof anyway....being financially unstable and all.
(2)
Report
See 5 more replies
That’s the problem I’m having.....my mom has dementia, she’ll be 98 next month. I was caring for her until brother took over her finances. After a few falls and hospitalization, he took her to a lawyer to have her sign unlimited DPOA & amended her trust to benefit himself 100% removing all other heirs.

After he did this if I tried to see or speak to her he would call the police and say I was harassing her. I had proof of him writing checks to himself for cash from her account. He ended up closing the account since my mom had my name on it also and opened a new account without my name.

He then moved a woman into her home who got evicted from her trailer park who has financial problem and has access to all mom’s personal info & finances. Money is being used from my mother’s account to support this woman.

I have not seen my mother in almost 2 years now and lawyers want a substantial retainer with no guarantees of outcome. If you find out what to do please let me know. Best wishes to you.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
ssnow04 Jul 2020
I'm so sorry to hear that. I would venture to say that once the money has run out, your brother probably won't have a problem with you seeing your mom. Be careful about that....if she has a large amount coming in each month, you may never get past him. If she doesn't and it's just money in a bank account, then once he has squandered it or squirreled it away somewhere, then all of a sudden he will act like..."of course you can see mom!" Message me if you want...I have several ideas. Maybe we can compare notes...lol.
(2)
Report
Sorry but you can not win.

My brother in law has stolen over 500 thousand dollars and I am supposed to smile because he is so cute. By the way he is 60 years old with a 25 year old phillopino bride.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
ssnow04 Jul 2020
That is probably true. Did your brother in law steal from his own mother that much? That is unbelievable, just like my OS, how they can justify taking that amount. I am very sorry to hear about that.
(1)
Report
Imho, that is indeed unfortunate. So even though my one sibling is an attorney, I found him to be using some of our late mother's finances to pay for his half of an item that we had covered our half on - whether it was just a simple "slip up," I caught it and then he paid his rightful share.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
ssnow04 Jul 2020
Thank you, it is unfortunate but now I know that she cannot be trusted ever. I'm sorry about your situation too. Take care
(1)
Report
Your situation and that of others on here are enough to make me want to spit fire. I just have to say, though, that the way I understand it is that your attorney while working on contingency does not get his fees if you don't get anything. However, what about his costs? Sometimes those are passed along to the client (forensic accountants, filing fees for complaints, expert consultations, etc.) You may want to read your contract.

Also, just to share the misery, my friend's sister is the "golden child," an animal hoarder with over 100 potbelly pigs, who are making more pigs as we speak. Friend's mom is 87 and wanted to live with sister, who lives like a hoarder lives. Between my friend's mom's social security and sister's disability they net about $2200 per month. They are spending $2000 per MONTH on pig food and supplies. I kid you not. My friend, who does the bookkeeping is fit to be tied as she has had to pay mom's food bills, sister's property tax (because mom lives there), but there is nothing she can do about the money hemorrhage because mom won't cut off sister ("poor thing, she can't support herself"), and won't move to Florida to be with my friend in a nice house. She would ather live in squalor in Pig Central in a crappy part of the California Central Valley and be watching over sister (who ignores her unless she needs money). People are nuts but seem to do whatever they want.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
ssnow04 Jul 2020
They definitely do what they want. My mom was that way...defending OS and OB. Now, she doesn't even mention their names. The sad part in all of this is that my mom, your friend's mom, and nameless others will never have the retirement / end of life comforts that they saved their life for. Thanks for your story.
(2)
Report
Nationwide issue. Watch Netflix Dirty Money episode Guardian Inc., read Dr. Sam Sugar’s book Guardianship The Elderly The Perfect Crime, Google cases like Besse Owens from Detroit, Harold Jackson Detroit, Voice Advocates Michigan, documentary Guardian in Las Vegas etc. Look up legal abuse syndrome, undue influence, undue process by Probate Judges in vulnerable elder and adult disabled guardianship info.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
ssnow04 Jul 2020
Thank you. I actually just watched the Netflix episode....very shocking to say the least. I will read up on the other items you noted. My OS really didn't have POA (until later) or guardianship, but she still managed to finagle everything out of my mom....my mom was very dependent and thought everything being done was for her so she would sign anything you put in front of her. I was granted guardianship after my mom lost everything but at least I don't have to worry about OS getting her claws in my mom's monthly income.
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
Husband’s brother got Durable POA and revised medical POA after MIL was diagnosed with dementia. Husband and sister kept asking for an accounting but brother claimed things were fine and the questions made him “nervous.” We moved back to the area and became more persistent in questions. Brother announced he was having her trust changed to put himself and his son in charge of all her money. We were able to get her to the attorney who finally realized she lacked sufficient awareness to make any changes. The attorney did agree to make the trust irrevocable with my husband in charge as her trustee. From there we went to the bank to learn that brother had helped himself to over $50,000. We contacted the state to report elder abuse, reported the theft to the police, and contacted an elder attorney. All agreed that it was virtually impossible to recover the money or prosecute as MIL could not (and probably would not) say anything against her baby. Husband went to Social Security to become her representative payee, and, because the POA was still outstanding, he went to court and was declared her legal guardian and conservator. All of this took six months and about $6,000. MIL was one of the lucky ones. She is now in a continuum of care facility and, at 97, we pray there is enough money left to last her lifetime.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report
ssnow04 Jul 2020
Boy, your story sounds so much like mine...awful. I now have guardianship along with reports to elder abuse, police and the elder attorney. Your husband's brother was probably broke or near broke....just a theory. I know my OS did what she did because of basically having no money from her bad financial choices in the past....so, she thought it was ok making my mom pay for her mistakes.
(3)
Report
My mom had dementia and owned her own home. My niece and her boyfriend moved in with Mom to care for her and her home (Niece and Boyfriend lived rent-free for doing so, which my sisters and I were good with). One day my sister (Niece's mom) called me breathing fire. She told me she looked at Mom's bank statement and ALL Mom's money was gone--to the tune of thousands.

Side note: I live in another state from my family. Now, Sisters did a lot for Mom and I always felt guilty. In talking with another sister I occurred to me that I could take on Mom's finances long distance if Sisters got Mom to sign a DPOA to me.

Mom would never file charges against Niece and even if Mom wanted to she wouldn't recall any of it anyway. Niece admitted to my sister that she knew Mom wouldn't remember giving her any money. Heck, there were a few days, Niece took Mom to the bank twice a day!

I got the DPOA. I developed a monthly statement that accounted for every penny of Mom's monthly. All of us agreed Mom would pay Niece and BF's moving expenses out. Once I got the DPOA, I told Niece, from my mouth to her ears, Mom (her grandmother) was in a protected class of vulnerable elders by state law. If Niece took even a penny from Mom I WOULD CALL THE POLICE AND HAVE HER ARRESTED. Niece never took a penny again.

That was the best I could do.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report
ssnow04 Jul 2020
Wow, that sounds like an awful experience. Your niece was probably being coaxed by her boyfriend to do that. At least she took your warning. My OS will not do anything with any kind of warning and she has taken in the hundreds of thousands. Thank you for your story. I'm glad your mom has you watching over her.
(4)
Report
Hi
It is a common situation - my mom has Alzheimers- and is in a full care facility- I witnessed multiple times my younger sibling writing checks to himself from her check book for gas, (he lived 2 miles from my mom's care home), expenses, groceries (my mom's mini fridge was always empty) misc, etc.
He had her credit card, check book, and debit card -every time I went to visit and take her out she wanted to pay or offer and had nothing . Her private nurse told me that "your mom doesn't have any money ever" My dad left her well off -I live out of the country. My brother said he kept her cards and check book to protect her from her nurse who he didn't trust. He fired the nurse and told me she quit. What he didn't know was that she called me every week to update me and told me they fired her weeks before his story.
My mom's nurse said my mom wanted to go out and pay for stuff but didn't know where her debit card was ...
my father who passed four years prior would have been livid if he knew what my brother was doing - two brothers - they helped themselves to her account, said they took her to appointments (hearing aids) never once did in four years - and it goes on and on - I found out and asked about it only to be cussed out and told that I am not there and have no business interfering-
so now we are estranged basically -
so
it get's ugly- I have had a daughter who has had 13 leg and ankle surgeries in the last four years and have been rehabbing her - I wish I could be closer as I am a great caregiver - disgusted in them
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
ssnow04 Jul 2020
Thanks so much for your story. It is awful how some siblings start thinking that it is their right to mom or dad's money just because. My parents scrimped and saved their entire life for a good retirement and look at my mom now...on medicaid and otherwise just a few dollars in her account.
(4)
Report
See 1 more reply
My experience here in Canada is that financial crimes are rarely prosecuted and even if they are it is very rare to have and of the stolen funds returned. You may get a judgement, but collecting is very difficult.

We almost lost our business and house when an employee who was also a family friend stole over $60k from us. She also did not make remittances to the CRA and we faced huge fines and penalties. She was the company bookkeeper.

We had proof, but needed a forensic audit, $25k to provide the proof to the RCMP.

Good Luck.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
ssnow04 Jul 2020
I believe that is true here too so I am prepared to get nothing for my mom, but it is a matter of trying to get some justice....just a smidge of it. If it is even possible. I wish there were more protection for vulnerable adults. As I said, the DCF was pretty much useless. Anyway, thanks again for responding. Take care.
(3)
Report
My OB basically robbed my parents blind. He stole their silver, Indian Artifacts, coin collections, tools, cars, anything of value. When he had cleaned them out of tangible things, he talked them into getting a Home Equity Line on their home (their only asset). This is back in 1997-98--he took $200K--which then was a LOT of money.

The rest of us 5 sibs knew nothing about this until YB finished the apartment on his home that was to house mom and dad for the remainder of their lives. The plan was that they'd pay off YB's home and he'd not ask any monetary recompense for taking care of them forever.

What a shock. The house was sold and Mother and Dad netted less than $60K where they should have had almost $300K. YB was never made whole--but we as kids all pitched in and helped as much as we could---but it was a real nightmare.

OB felt completely fine about doing this. It was unbelievable. Of course all the money was long gone....did we even talk about going after him? No, b/c he was the golden boy and mother wouldn't allow it.

It was her call, as it was her money--and dad was too deep into Parkinson's dementia to understand what had happened.

In this case as in so many, you have to weigh the possibility of getting the money back against the emotional cost. To mother, who loved OB with an almost sick fascination--this was clearly not the thing to do.

OB died, completely destitute about 8 years ago.

She and dad were the ones who suffered. YB was eventually made whole, but not immediately. When mother dies, we all inherit the same amount. It's a very small amount. As I have done a LOT of CG for mom, I may or may not accept my 'inheritance'..or I may simply give it to YB. She's been there 22 years. Daddy lived for 8 years there.

Mother is sliding into dementia, but she is still 'with it' enough to not bring up OB's name in conversation. He left enough pain and hurt behind him to last us all a lifetime.

Each situation is unique--and also the same. I have 5 kids and I cannot IMAGINE any one of them doing something so horrible. Mother has a real blind eye when it comes to this brother.

Whatever you decide, I wish you luck. There really is no 'right' nor 'wrong' in a case like this. Just 'awful' and 'slightly less awful'.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
ssnow04 Jul 2020
Thank you so much for your story, and I am truly sorry you had to go through that too. It sounds like it was almost too late to try and recover anything for your parents. You are right, they are the ones who suffer. My mom used to feel grateful that she had kids "taking care of her." Now, she never even mentions OS and OB. There is always a golden child, and my OB was it, but he wasn't as guilty as OS. In our case, there is still something to recover as she thought it was ok to rob my mom blind and then buy 2 houses with that money. I think the advice I would give anyone going into their golden years with adult kids: take a good look at your kids each one, their history with managing money and a true look at their character before deciding on which one to trust as a POA. My child is disabled so I will be taking care of him for his life, not the other way around. It is not against the rule book to have an income trust or special needs trust set up and a care plan for yourself. My OS did something I couldn't see coming (we tend to give a sister or brother the benefit of the doubt) but at the same time, she had filed for bankruptcy, had three bad divorces, and is quite the spendthrift. My mom was her only way to hijack the life she wanted back.
(2)
Report
Glad you are getting legal help; so many come to the forum asking what to do, and often legal is the only route, and yes, is it EVER expensive. Hope you will update us on the outcome and provide any information you think might be helpful to other caregiver families.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
ssnow04 Jul 2020
Thank you, I will. I feel a little alone on this. I hope there are people on this forum that have had this experience.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter