Follow
Share

Just joined.


I'm trying very hard not to "take over" and "do things for them" (mom and step-dad). My grandmother helped me to understand how awful it is to have someone be "helpful" and in reality just take away her agency and actually make things more inconvenient. So I'm really sensitive to not "taking over."

It all seems silly I know, but the more I try not to "take over" the more I feel like I end up taking over. And I'm not sure what feels like the greater challenge right now.

IDK, I feel like I should be happier about it all (happy that I'm here to help), but I often just end up feeling sad. And that makes me feel confused and awful.


It just feels impossible to articulate anything. I feel ashamed because I'm not doing a better job of handling the mental decline of my parents--both of whom used to manage multi million dollar budgets and large staffs. And now there is no decision too small to be confusing. I'm frustrated. Sad. Confused. Disoriented. Mad. So incredibly concerned that I'm losing them. And I feel awful for feeling any of it. I feel like a wuss for making any of it about me.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
We are here to listen and help. Our caregiving experiences help us to help others.

Caregiving is hard. It would help if u tell us why you feel incompetent.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Calliope Sep 2020
Replied above. Hope I did this correctly. New to this format and would welcome lessons on how to do this correctly. Sorry for the newbieness.
(1)
Report
Welcome Calliope, hope you find this Forum helpful.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Calliope Sep 2020
Thanks for the welcome.
(2)
Report
Hello, Calliope

Why do you feel incompetent? Is the person you are caring for obese? Do you feel guilty or afraid of certain consequences if you don’t give a second helping of food? Can you clarify your question for us? Thanks.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Calliope Sep 2020
Thank you for taking the time to reach out. Please see my clarification above. Much appreciated.
(1)
Report
Yes we need some clarification. Everyone knows that food=love from early childhood when mother was the source of food. Food is a very complicated issue. Please explain why you ended up feeling badly.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Calliope Sep 2020
Thank you for the reply. Please see my responses above. Appreciate your time.
(0)
Report
I'm trying very hard not to "take over" and "do things for them" (mom and step-dad). My grandmother helped me to understand how awful it is to have someone be "helpful" and in reality just take away her agency and actually make things more inconvenient. So I'm really sensitive to not "taking over."

So now I go in to make lasagna with mom (something she has made excellently hundreds and hundreds of times) and I'm not just a helper, but I'm now in charge of deciding how many eggs in the ricotta, what temp the oven should be, how much meat and onion we should put in the sauce, what spices we add, but when it comes to assembly there in only ONE way it all gets layered, but worse the more I try not to "take over" the more I'm the one who made dinner and I feel lost and I don't even know what I'm supposed to be doing. Or I go to buy a new grill with step-father and I have to decide if the grill he wants is okay, or should we get the other one, does this one look alright and is it big enough, is the other one a better brand, do we need four burners or is three enough, etc, and when I choose one for him he tells customer service to send someone over to show him how to light it--right after I show him the manual and demonstrate how it lights....just short of infuriating and then I have to thank the store associate profusely for taking the time to show us how to light a grill when I had it figured out before anyone asked for help. And some days it just feels non-stop from all directions. It all seems silly I know, but the more I try not to "take over" the more I feel like I end up taking over. And I'm not sure what feels like the greater challenge right now.

IDK, I feel like I should be happier about it all (happy that I'm here to help), but I often just end up feeling sad. And that makes me feel confused and awful.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I apologize for the confusion. I was talking about feeling guilty about putting another helping on the plate of fellow care givers. I was not in any way trying to suggest I was over feeding a parent. So sorry to confuse.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Sep 2020
Oh, okay. Thanks for explaining that to us.

First of all let me say that you have absolutely no reason to apologize to us. You have an enormous responsibility caring for your family.

We understand how challenging being a caregiver is. Many of us have been in your shoes and are taking care of our parents too or have done so in the past.

Free yourself of the guilt that you feel. It’s very easy to become overwhelmed. It happened to me all the time when I was caring for my parents.

It’s okay to be frustrated by certain things too. Let me tell you that I don’t know one single caregiver that always had a smile on their face. Sometimes we get annoyed, even down right angry at certain times. Guess what? That makes you completely normal!

You don’t sound like a ‘takeover’ personality at all. You just sound frustrated and most likely tired. As far as the cooking goes, just do what you can. Your best is good enough.

Same with the shopping and what your stepdad does after purchasing an item.

You can’t control his actions or behavior. My mom would come behind me after I did something and question it or even totally screw it up and it would drive me nuts too.

Oh how I wish I had let the little things go by the wayside because I truly did not have any control over my mom’s behavior.

It’s a clash in personality issue. No two people agree all of the time or always understand each other.

It’s just not worth the headache to expect everything to run smoothly all the time.

If your stepdad calls for a service person to come out, just let them while you sit back and enjoy a cup of tea. Let them explain it ten times to him. Trust me I had to learn this the hard way.

You care about your family. That is admirable but you also have to care about yourself just as much.

Don’t worry about others criticizing you if you know that you have done your best. A lot of people who criticize don’t have a clue what is going on. Ignore anything that is petty. If it is a legitimate concern then you can address it.

Sorry this message ended up being so long. I saw some of myself in your post and wanted to try to help if I could.

Take care and wishing you all the best to you and your family.
(10)
Report
We are here to listen and support. We do this site voluntarily to help others. 🙂
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
Calliope Sep 2020
Thank you.
(3)
Report
It just feels impossible to articulate anything. I feel ashamed because I'm not doing a better job of handling the mental decline of my parents--both of whom used to manage multi million dollar budgets and large staffs. And now there is no decision too small to be confusing. I'm frustrated. Sad. Confused. Disoriented. Mad. So incredibly concerned that I'm losing them. And I feel awful for feeling any of it. I feel like a wuss for making any of it about me.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Sep 2020
In no way are you a wuss! Not at all. Your feelings are completely normal.

I want you to read what you just wrote. They have changed. Of course it isn’t their fault because of the mental decline and yes, it’s extremely frustrating because they were obviously very accomplished successful people before their health issues. It’s heartbreaking to say the least.

You don’t have any reason to feel guilt or shame. No one can handle this situation perfectly. No one! I’m sure anyone on this forum can attest to that.

I wish that I could say something to comfort you but I am aware that you are in the midst of an extremely trying situation and my words are of little help. I’m so sorry that you are struggling with this. It’s hard. It’s sad.

Have you spoken to a social worker about their behavior? Their doctor or hospital can recommend a social worker to speak with and that was a big help to me in sorting out things with my parents. They can point out things that we sometimes miss when we are overwhelmed.
(5)
Report
See 1 more reply
And I'm afraid that because I'm not handling it well that it makes it worse for them to handle it. And the last thing I want to do is make it harder for them. And the cycle just eats me up. And I feel like I should be doing better. And I'm upset that I'm not. And because I can't figure it all out I feel emotionally incompetent.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Sep 2020
Okay, that’s understandable. I get that. Have you considered speaking to someone for yourself?

I went to a therapist when I was completely stressed out and it was the best thing that I could have done for myself. It helped a lot. My situation remained the same but my reaction to the situation improved greatly.

You are doing everything that I used to do. I felt responsible for everything and when I couldn’t fix it immediately I felt like a failure. Life is difficult and isn’t solved that easily.

Sometimes it’s one baby step at a time, one day at the time.
(5)
Report
Can I reply to a reply? If so, how?

Or do I bring all responses to the top?

Guess I need to find the forum rules page....which is where?
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Sep 2020
You have to click on the name where it says, ‘reply to.’ There is ‘helpful answer’ above it. It’s underneath the message or you can click on the name to privately message them. Or you can continue to type in the main forum. Most people read both sections.

Not sure where the forum rules are. You’ll get the hang of it.
(1)
Report
Yep, got your private message. Do you know how to get yours? Go to profile and you will see it.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Calliope,

Just checking in. Check your settings to see if you are set up to receive messages. I replied to your private message.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Calliope,
I think I am frustrated as I cannot imagine how to respond to you when I do not understand your situation. I need a picture drawn for me, by you.
Can you tell us a little bit of what is happening to you and your parents?
Don't worry about the confusion and terror you are experiencing right now; that is normal and will be bound to make you anxious. Remember, this is all new to you. About two years ago I took over management of my brother's estate; I knew nothing and I honestly didn't even know what I didn't know. It took me a while to get it ironed out, a day at a time. By the time I felt semi-competent he died, and then I was on for being executor, and trustee of an irrevocable trust. Another learning curve commenced.
Try to slow down a little bit and give us perhaps one concrete description of ONE question you have about something that troubles you today. One at a time people can help you through with suggestions and ideas. This may not be for you; that is to say you may find you are unable to do this, and if guardianship is needed you may decide to turn it over to the State and to a Fiduciary hired by them, and to just be there to visit and help.
Slow yourself and calm yourself as much as you can, and remember, not a soul here who has not know a feeling of great helplessness one time or another. What you are feeling is absolutely normal.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Calliope,
People are trying to sending to "private messages".
1. Go to the upper right hand side of the page.
2. Press on the circle with a "C" in it.
3. Then Press on "settings"
4. On the line below, on settings, you will see "privacy". Press on that word
5. Now you can set your settings to on or off for receiving and answering private messages.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Consider asking your parents for easier choices: choice in beverage, choice in vegetables for dinner, choice in clothes to wear.... You allow people appropriate options and don't have to worry about either choice being the wrong choice. My mother has only the smallest beginnings of dementia and she has always hated having too many options. She always feared choosing the wrong one. So, I offer her acceptable options and limit the choices to 2-3 which she is happier to chose from.

As for doing things, always let people do as much as they can for themselves. Most folks with dementia will only need "prompting" in the early stages: brush teeth, brush hair, wash hands.... Eventually it will get tough to remember how to do tasks and then you may need to take over.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Since you haven't really provided any description of their condition(s), it makes it difficult to address your concerns. We don't need the nitty gritty details, it's none of our business, but it does sound like there are cognitive challenges going on. Is this for both of them? Have they had thorough exams and Dx?

One of the comments you made about the grill is concerning, given we don't know what the scoop is. Helping to decide which grill to buy is one thing, having to have you or someone else explain multiple times how to start it is concerning. If he has some form of dementia, should he be operating a gas grill? Would he forget to turn it off? Leave it unattended, potentially causing a fire? Turn the burners off but leave the gas on? Gas stoves don't mix well with cognitive issues (electric too, but gas is much worse!)

If they are having cognitive declines, it is good to keep them active, helping out when they can, socializing as much as possible, getting exercise and good nutrition. But, if they are trying to make something like lasagna and you find yourself having to take over, it is likely because they can't do it! Until we took mom's car away, I had no way to know she wasn't cooking anymore. I had to take her shopping, and when I would come for the next trip, no meat from freezer was used and the fresh vegetables in the refrigerator were all nasty, unused. She simply couldn't follow instructions to make things anymore. Microwave foods, prepackaged fruits and boxed stuff was about it. This despite her mantra being she was "fine, independent and could cook!" She isn't, wasn't and couldn't!

Again, I'm only guessing that you are dealing with cognitive declines. If that is the case, you will have to take over, a little at a time, as they will become less and less able to process what needs to be done, step by step. Do encourage them to do what they are still capable of doing, it helps to keep them active and feel like they are contributing, but don't feel that you are stepping in, taking over and causing problems! It is more likely they just can't do these things anymore.

It really doesn't matter what they did in their "previous" life. The awful consequences of cognitive issues are devastating, no matter how smart and/or capable one was before!
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I don't know if you have a diagnosis for either parent, but clearly there is some cognitive decline going on.

"Taking over" becomes inevitable with time ... and yes, it feels horribly wrong. Still, it's necessary.

Over several years, my late father-in-law went from being our computer guru - to being on our tech level - to asking more questions from us than we asked him - to forgetting some tasks he used to do routinely - and finally, to having difficulties every time he booted up.

During his last couple of years, it took both of my sisters-in-law, one tech consultant working remotely, plus myself, just to help him do simple tasks (and very often, to just go ahead and do them ourselves). It was his lifeline, and we were available.

(Oh, and after all that, he'd often take the PC down to his favorite computer shop for "repairs.")

My mother-in-law had to take over the household finances. One of my sisters-in-law handled his meds. Both of them had to take over the driving. All of these were HIS domains, once upon a time.

He did not always like it. OK, he mostly didn't like it (except for the tech support). But over time, he came to accept each change.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

As I think about it, your feelings seem to be normal in our “crazy-normal” lives. It is all so painful. Parents/spouses used to take care of us and now the roles are reversed. We are saddened by the loss of who they were, uncomfortable with our new roles which don’t come with clear directions. I am glad you can ventilate here but feel sad myself for all the suffering of very good people here who are just trying to do their best. I should take my own advice because I can be very irritable with my husband and need to accept that as a famous psychoanalyst said “We are all more human than otherwise.”
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Yes they need your help, yes they hate it and yes they will blame you for a bit. Yes they are no longer who they were. Yes you will feel awful. It can all be part of the deal. Try to use humor when you can, it eases some of the emotions for all parties. Keep on keepin' on, keep yourself educated on elder care, and use us to vent!
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

I wish there were more family members like you!

I also wish you weren't feeling so bad. You feel bad about your parents' decline, bad about how you're supporting them through it, and now - bad about sharing with us????!!!

You are doing all the right things. The reason you feel bad (the only reason left) is that decline sucks, and the best answers may still not be attractive. But that doesn't make any of it your fault, you know.

There are whole text books on supporting decision-making in people with limited or diminishing mental capacity; but the key thing that I think you'll find encouraging is to remember that this is not an On/Off switch. Those small decisions which are still so confusing: you can break them down for your parents, and support them in continuing to process what they can. So, e.g.:

What would you like for breakfast?
becomes
Would you like eggs or cereal this morning?
becomes
Would you like eggs? [Yes/No]
[If no] Would you like cereal?
and eventually becomes
Here is your cereal/eggs/bacon sandwich/apple sauce/etc. [but still leaving the person the option of refusing food, in which case you offer an alternative or two]

So even at that last stage your parent must still have the option of saying yes or no.

Another approach is to wait. Suppose a decision has to be made about... fitting a stairlift, just for example. There is a lot of information to gather and to consider. As well as breaking the information down into digestible formats, you can also consider timing. Maybe the decision-maker has more energy and alertness in the late mornings. Then you can keep checking how the person seems to be coping - if they're becoming tired or overwhelmed, end the discussion (noting what the person has expressed so far) and come back to it later.

If they're presented with a spreadsheet, still offer them the spreadsheet but also give them the information summarised in a legible and comprehensible format. The same with documents and leaflets and brochures - the bullet point list is your friend. If one way of explaining (or of supporting memory) doesn't work, try another. There are almost as many approaches as there are people.

In reablement we have rules of thumb such as "try, but don't struggle." Let your parent try. Don't let him/her struggle and become discouraged.

Your own feelings about their entering the last stages of life are a different issue. Do you have any support for yourself?

I have to know: what does "doing a better job of handling the mental decline" look like, please? Do you know *anyone* who is actually good at this?
Helpful Answer (16)
Report

Yes - I've had all these feelings too. I think it's a way for us to process the loss of the parent(s) we used to know - which causes conflict in us because they are still here. The most difficult thing for me was knowing where to draw the line between taking over for Mom or letting her continue to do things for herself. As it became more obvious that she was changing, I just started doing the things she couldn't until it became too much for me. I'm not sure but I think that made her feel like she was still OK on her own. Probably I was the enabler in that. She refused to look at Assisted Living facilities and became very irate when when my brothers and I suggested it. That was unfortunate because I think she might have actually come to like it. It was frustrating and confusing but now I realize she just couldn't think through complex issues and come up with workable solutions.

Mom's in a nursing home now and seems to be doing pretty well. I can't visit inside yet but we talk by the window. I know the Mom who has always been my best friend isn't able to have those long conversations we would always have or help me work through a problem. I feel this is preparing me for when she's no longer here. The feeling of loss is there but incremental. Sometimes I'm OK with it, other times - not so much. This sure isn't an easy road for any of us. Just know your heart is in the right place and what you decide will be because you love your folks and want the best for them.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

To help prepare for when the time comes you have to make decisions for a parent on your own is not easy if their plans or not already documented and confirmed on video of their wishes that they want you and only you to handle all their affairs medical and financial and have all documents and video given to attorney and doctor. If not done this way a court appointed guardian usually an attorney will be making all decisions medical and financial and you have no say when you will be able to even visit. Maybe talk about you being guardian while parent can still make that decision and Petition Probate court to do just that. There are many videos online to explain how process works and get elder attorney referral from a family member or someone else you can trust. Each state’s protocol may be a little different. As long as you are there for a parent when they need you makes life a lot easier for them, but if life becomes an everyday struggle and safety issues is when it is a good time to step in and do what is necessary to protect them.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I think you may be overwhelmed. Which is understandable. You are doing these things because you want to help. So, is there anything they can do for themselves? If so, let them. Maybe they have just gotten used to you doing everything and stopped doing for themselves. Good luck.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

You are way over-thinking it, my dear. Your not taking over, you are simply doing your best.
Try to find joy in the little, day-to-day things and it'll get easier.
Check in as often as you like,
We are here for you.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

You have lots of good answers here.

A book that might be helpful is Karen Kissel's "How to Be a Help Instead of a Nuisance: Practical Approaches to Giving Support, Service & Encouragement to Others.

Take care

With prayers and friendship
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

It is very sad and an emotional time to see your very intelligent parents declining. Its very hard on them too. Allow them to do as much as they can on their own. So much independence has already been taken away. My dad died 3 months ago and we were all hovering around mom. She was difficult and argumentative so after deciding to take a step back she is resuming some activities and is happier.
She has a private sitter each evening. We still ask about things concerning her apartment because after all it is her home.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Juse do your best.
Let your parents do what they can even if they're taking longer to do it.

Ask if they want help with this or that.
Help when they're trying and seem to have difficulty doing the task.
Don't rush them.
It takes my 96 yr old Dad an hour to eat but he feeds himself and that's a good thing.
Give them Love and plenty of patience.

Do the best you can and hire Caregivers to help as you will burn out real soon trying to do it all by yourself.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I am so sorry for what you are going through. This is such a confusing time and you probably don’t even know where to start. You are not alone.

Most if us will probably decline slowly as we age and we all hope people will be there for us.

Fly into the storm and be there for your parents as they decline. You will never regret it.

This is very hard, but you will get through. Make sure you take care of yourself too - get exercise, eat right, don’t let yourself decline too.

Make sure you have what help you need, so that your relationship with your parents can be focused on love and not just labor. Treat their caretakers with respect - let them do their job- and don’t get jealous when your parents show them love.

Be kind to yourself. This ongoing loss is painful and acknowledge (to yourself) that you are hurting. Most of all, don’t run away from the problem. Someday when you look back on this time, you will be grateful that you were there. If you run or stay away (because it’s too painful) you will feel regret and it will be too late to correct. Anyone can be there in the good times, but the true friends are there when times are tough.

If your parents say something off, it hurts. You want to get “them” back. But don’t correct them. Just love them as they are. Who they are today may be the best they will ever be. If you correct them, they might grow afraid of making mistakes and quit talking as much. Someday you will be glad for every conversation and every good day. Make your relationship a safe place for them and you will have more good days.

My mom died in my arms, surrounded by my three young children. It is incomprehensible, even as I write this to remember that moment. But afterward, my pre-teen said there was no place that she would have rather been, that she felt appreciative that she could have been there for her grandmother to help her grandmother through such a difficult time.

Her words gave me strength as losing my mom was my lifetime’s worst nightmare.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
cherokeegrrl54 Sep 2020
I’m so sorry for the loss of your beloved mother. You have written such wise words of advice to all caregivers....thank you! Liz💖
(5)
Report
Hi, I'm not an aggressive or take-over type person, but when I started taking care of my mom I found so often that she would not like the way I did things and want them done her way. It was so hard because I was 64 at that time and had developed my own style of living in this world. Adjusting to hers seemed an impossibility. She was able to demand how things should be done without being able to do them herself. There was so much confusion and feelings of losing myself in her world of doubt, suspicion, paranoia, anger, and forgetfulness. Some things I thought were just nuts, like requiring the washing machine water to be filled to full when there was only a half load of clothes, turning the heat to 85 while wearing just a thin sleeveless nightie, and running the disposal for a full 3 minutes. When I hung some blankets out to dry in the sun she accused me of announcing to the neighbors that we were poor and couldn't afford a dryer. OMG, what??!! All this was before her memory got really bad. I had to learn to not even try to get my own way unless her way was actually dangerous. Eventually she came to depend on my judgement about absolutely everything. She trusts me completely now and answers most questions with, "you'll have to ask my daughter". I had to become somewhat of a take-over person. She's in Assisted Living now, but I visit her at her window or on her porch. Day by day you learn how to cope. And you get help. You can't do it alone. And the care giving duties change little by little as your parents decline. And you will be sad and confused and angry and exhausted sometimes. Continue talking about all that. It might be good to break down specific details about what bothers you most and see how each of those things can be approached differently one at a time.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Sep 2020
Oh my gosh, you expressed the situation so well for what many people go through. Thanks so much for for sharing your experiences.
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
I think one of the hardest parts of this for my husband and his brother was wrapping their minds around the fact that their capable and competent, in charge dad could no longer grasp how to do simple tasks and that they couldn’t “show him” And have him remember. My husband set out to “teach him” much like you described. You need to accept and grasp the fact that that part of your parents is gone. It will not return. Instead you need to find ways to lovingly come alongside and level the path to keep them from tripping and falling, both literally and figuratively. Remove the things that are dangerous or cause too much distress. I think a Gas grill is too much if he can’t grasp how to light it. Imagine if you are not there and he turns on the gas and leaves it running? Or forgets to turn off the flame 🔥. Instead of trying to help your mom figure out how to make lasagna, make some for her and put them in the freezer to take out and bake. Or make some and bring it and eat it with them and say how thankful you are that she is such a good cook and shared that skill with you and how her great skills will be passed down for generations. It is not guilt you are feeling-it is grief. Give yourself permission to grieve and take everything one day at a time. One of the hard things to accept both for them and for you is that this will NOT get better....so grieve what is lost and take all the rest one day at a time.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter