Follow
Share

All my mother's life my uncle, her brother, has always been controlling of her. Recently he has fallen ill, he keeps my mother on the phone for up to 4 hours and I overheard conversations where he keeps saying mean things and she has to defend herself. He has been begging her to come to stay with him a couple of days just for a visit. She is 85 and in good health, has an active social life with friends and neighbors.


I tried to convince her not to go or only go for a couple of hours, she insisted she stay 1 week. He lives 2 hours away. She told me the entire time he verbally abused her, he has no food, none in the fridge and told her nobody delivers to his house so eat cookies. It was over 90 degress he refused to put on the AC, then he told my mother to get to work on his garden in the hot weather, she almost fainted, I'm sure there are many things she didn't mention to me, because she is severly shooken up and very depressed now. She tells me she should of listened to me and won't go there again, but she is under his control. (he doesn't give her money and has stated he is leaving her Nothing) It's just an abusive relationship... it's been going for years and now getting worse as he is sick. If she decides to go back is there someone I can report this to? If this abuse continues?


Also his childen are not nice people, I have no relationship with them

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
Unless your mom is not cognizant you can not do anything. It is her free will that she is going to him.
If you personally hear a threat you could report it.
If your mom becomes ill due to staying with her brother you might then convince her not to go.
YOU could go with her and if there is a situation that you think is not safe you can then tell mom...ok, we have had enough, let's go. And leave.
If he becomes violent while you are there or threatens either one of you while you are there you can report it, call 911. Tell the dispatcher you have been threatened.
IF your uncle is not competent you could help your mom seek Guardianship
Or if he is hospitalized if there is no one to care for him your mom could say that he should not be discharged to his home as it is unsafe.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Family is great...until it's not.

Your mom can do as she chooses. She doesn't HAVE to talk to OB for 4 hrs and take abuse. SHe can hang up. She can block his phone number! She doesn't have to even acknowledge his existence!

And, rarely do you see sibs leaving inheritances to each other esp if there are kids involved.

He also doesn't owe her money or anything other than familial kindness, which sounds like it's sadly missing.

You have no relationship with his kids? Fine. Encourage her to stop talking to him, completely.

I am curious--HOW does a 95 yo man 'control' someone who is 2 hrs away from her?

You can only encourage her to stand up for herself and that seriously is as easy as blocking his phone number or using caller ID to know when NOT to pick up the phone.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
marcie88 Jun 2021
Thank you! It's just been a pattern her whole life which got worse after my father died, He also has been controlling me and my siblings lives and constantly meddeling, He is very loud, agressive, controlling and a bully most of his life. My Mom is just the opposite, He calls almost everyday, when she wants to get off the phone, he will keep telling her to stay on. My husband drove her to his house, If i say he can't drive her then her brother says he will get one of his sons/grandsons to pick her up and demand it which I don't want. He also involves his family with backing him up.
(1)
Report
I'd change your mother's phone number and not let your uncle have it. That may be the best way to shoo him out of her life once and for all.

Otherwise, your mother is a grown woman and like Grandma said, if she is competent and not suffering from dementia, she can make her own decisions about how much abuse she's willing to take from her brother.

Good luck!
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
sp19690 Jun 2021
No she has PTSD and must be protected from the brother.
(2)
Report
I would call him and read him the riot act for treating my mom that way.

Maybe getting his azz chewed would stop him from doing it to mom.

They are from a generation that was very male authority figure, so I assume that he is the elder male in her life. Tell her it is okay for her to stop being his doormat. She needs to hear that it is okay for her not to take his abuse. She deserves better and he deserves a swift kick in the teeth for treating her that way.

Give her lots of love and help her feel like she is important after he has obviously torn her down. Sheesh! What a POS he is.

I would call her phone provider and have his and his off springs phone numbers blocked.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
marcie88 Jun 2021
Yes I agree, its that culture from that generation, he is the male authority figure in her family since her father died at a young age. When my father was alive, he wasn't that bad but still the same way. Hopefully she will listen to me and stand up for herself.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
OK, she is home with you now, and agrees you were right. Stop the "but she is under his control. " You got her back, she is safe, and you can monitor the phone calls.. as in hang the heck up! Does she need him to give her money? If he has no food you could look into getting him meals on wheels or report him as in need,, but do not let her go back or let him continue to abuse her . He seems not have wanted a visitor, but unpaid help.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Regardless of his mental status - the brother is a bully. Call it out & help your Mom stand up to him.

Your Mother has probably never learned to stand up to him. It will be hard but essential she does now, even after a lifetime.of this pattern.

You are very concerned for her. I would arrange some councelling, explain it can help to speak to an impartial non-family member about these matters. You could go along too, or not as you both decide. If no face to face options available, may be as tech support for a video call.

Religious elders often have councelling experience too & if your Mom is a person of faith, she may like that option better. That may be more like having a chat to a friend.

My parents have received good (& free) councelling advice from church elders in the past & I have had very good advice from my local Doctor too.

Some times when a third party gives permission to say no or decide for yourself what contact you want - it can make all the difference.

If this Uncle/Brother is needing a lot of help - it is up to him to source it. He can ask your Mother... but she can decline. He has no right at all to demand WHO provides the help. If he has dementia, his Enduring POA (if one) needs to arrange his care. If none, Guardianship is needed. This does not need to be his Next of Kin - in fact sometimes that is not recommended as it destroys any good left in the relationship.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Block this horrible person's number on your mother phone so he can't call her. Your mother has been abused by her brother all her life. She is unable to stand up for herself so it's your job to do it for her. Also call said brother and read him the riot act. Tell him he is abusive and if he keeps trying to contact your mother you will call the police and charge him with harassment. I don't care how old this pos is and I hope he is 10 feet under sooner rather than later.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Report him for abuse to Elder Protective Services for the best interest of your mother. Brother seems emotionally unstable.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Last Dec he wouldn’t turn on the heat. Let’s face it, your mom is not going to give up on this brother. I’m glad she’s home. Did she buy him groceries this time as well? By now she should know the drill. Did she drive there on her own?
I’m not sure what you would report. Your mom perhaps has memory loss? You aren’t keeping her out of harms way? A 95 yr old has a magnetic pull yet demonic manner?

I know it must drive you crazy but other than come here every few months and vent, I’m not sure what you can do but to accept that your mom is going to keep doing what she’s been doing. One begins to see why his children stay away.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

https://www.agingcare.com/questions/uncle-and-cousins-want-my-mother-to-be-a-caregiver-how-do-i-stop-them-taking-advantage-of-her-463385.htm

I thought Mom learned to ignore him in ur first post. She needs to ignore his calls. Don't pick up. What is he going to do to her?
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
marcie88 Jun 2021
Thanks, yes it's been 5 months, he convinced her to come back. I told her based on what happened last time and the recent phone conversations it's not a bad idea, she got very angry at me and said she has to see him. (His control again) Well this time it was 100 times worse, the abuse much worse to the point that she is very hurt by him. Ignoring his calls is a good idea I hope she listens to me.
(1)
Report
What a shame that your uncle treats your mom so shabbily. You know that he isn’t going to change and telling him off won’t make a bit of difference to him, except to possibly make him more ornery. I seriously doubt that he would listen to what you have to say or even care about what you think of his behavior.

If you are interested in doing something to make a difference, you could change mom’s number or block her brother’s number. Still, this would only work if your mom doesn’t turn around and give him her new number or unblock him.

Hopefully, your mom won’t go back for a visit to his home. I wouldn’t bother mentioning any of this to his children since you say that they aren’t nice people. Don’t waste any time or energy on them.

Wishing you and your mom all the best.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
sp19690 Jun 2021
Absolutely she should tell this abuser off and tell him not to call mom anymore. That if he does she will report him for harassment.
(3)
Report
marcie - do you think your mother suffers from Battered Women Syndrome? Seems like she can't leave him, and keeps coming back for more abuse.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Jun 2021
Good point. I wonder how her brother treated her when growing up together. Not all siblings have a loving relationship. There are many dysfunctional families. A long time ago these situations weren’t openly discussed. There were no support groups either. Very sad.
(2)
Report
Have you considered that your mother is not mentally well if she continues to be subjected to his behavior? If it were me, I'd interfere in the pattern of abuse.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

"Battered Women Syndrome" is a good question. Can't remember but is this a cultural thing? Men rule! Its going to be hard for an 85 year old to break away from years of abuse. What did your Dad think of this relationship?

Hopefully Mom finally learned after this last time. All you can do is support her in that his demands are wrong. He is not obligated to help him. He may be 93 but she is getting older to. I would not in any way drive her to see him. So he is leaving her nothing. Does he have anything to give? Was she always in the Will. No, you can't report this abuse because she is competent to make up her own mind.

Seems like when she isn't there his family isn't helping him either. I may call APS and tell them he is a vulnerable adult but that they are not to get you or your 85 yr old Mom involved because of his abuse. Give them info on his own children. Tell Mom the County will make sure he is OK so she no longer has to worry.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
sp19690 Jun 2021
She absolutely can report this abuse. There are laws to protect the elderly even if they are of sound mind and she needs to block this piece of trash from moms phone. 96 years old and still a vile human being tell him what you think of him maybe it will put him in the grave sooner from shock.
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
That generation of women placed men on a pedestal. I remember hearing women say that men were the boss and they knew what was best. Men were considered to be the head of the household

It never dawned on women back then that they had choices. For the most part they didn’t see themselves as being equal to men.

I remember hearing about my grandfather’s brothers being philanders. Well, one of my great aunt’s had money before she married my great uncle. She inherited a large home and ran a boarding house. So, she was an independent woman who didn’t rely on my great uncle for her survival. He ran around on her and she immediately packed up his belongings and dropped off his suitcases to her mother in law’s house. She told her mother in law that she could have her son back! LOL, very bold in that day.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
marcie88 Jun 2021
My Mom never broke out of that 1940's- 50's mentality unfortuantly. LOL good for your Great Aunt! Yes that is unusual for back then.
(2)
Report
Can you nobble her phone and block his number? Or divert his calls to your number? - that would be even better, you could tell the old bustard to f**k off and never call again. And let's hope the shock wouldn't kill him, eh.

If you don't understand yet why she is still so much under his sway, it isn't likely you ever will. But you can meet fire with fire. If she insists on going to his house again physically, can you insist that she doesn't go without you? - then you can either keep stalling, or go and give him a piece of your mind.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Jun 2021
Oooooh, I love the idea of forwarding his calls. Great suggestion! I suppose that I can be a bit devious at times but wouldn’t it be funny to forward his call to somewhere like a recorded message like, ‘Dial a Prayer.’ 😂 LOL

Actually, there are great choices to forward his number to, the zoo, since he’s acting like an uncivilized creature. Perhaps a mental hospital, since he is unstable.

What about a funeral home to remind him where he is going! I doubt that he is interested in changing his ways before checking out but hey…

The list is endless. The forwarding number would block him and he would be hanging in limbo with nowhere to direct his abuse! Problem solved!
(3)
Report
just an update: My Mom has been complaining to me everyday for hours about how badly she was abused by my Uncle, last night my husabnd took her to ER beause she was having pain in her legs, she told us she was on her knees cleaning uncles floors which she did not tell me when she came back. She has a hairline fracture in her knee which is already arthritic. Me, my husband and my siblings had a long talk with my Mom who agreed she will not call her her brother. That he is very abuse and she promised to keep her distance.
Today she broke her promise and called him and the same pattern is happening all over. I really give up at this point and feel hurt and let down by this. I just feel like walking away. Obviously theres nothing I can do, she lies and calls him.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
sp19690 Jun 2021
She needs to be protected from him. It is now your job to keep him from calling her and vice versa . it is like battered woman's syndrome. Both you and your husband need to have a talk with him about this and tell him he is not to call her anymore or you will make a police report for harassment. She may never tell you but she has been abused by brother since she was a child.
(2)
Report
See 2 more replies
You need to go pick up your mother before something really bad happens to her. Get the police to escort you over there to remove your mother from her brother's house immediately. Do not ever let her go back over there! Report all this to the police about the abuse. Block the brothers number on your house phone and all cell phones. Your mom needs your help. Be proactive!
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
marcie88 Jun 2021
Thank you, she is back home now for 1 week from his house, everyday for hours on end she kept telling me how he verbally abused her and how she will not call him, today she went back to the abuse by calling him.
If I block the #'s she will call him anyway, she broke her promise to me and my family about not calling him
(1)
Report
marcie - there are women who LOVE to be abused so that they can ENJOY complaining about the mistreatment and GAIN sympathy. One of my uncle's wife is like that. He abused her physically and mentally, yet all she did was complaining about the abuse ENDLESSLY and with RELISH because she would retell the same stories with all the unpleasant details again and again to ANYONE who would listen. She did not take any advice other family members gave her or do anything to stop the abuse. Even after they got divorced, she went back to him.

Your mother seems to be one of those women. Very unfortunate. Nothing anyone can do. Your mother is doing what she wants and enjoys.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
marcie88 Jun 2021
Thanks, sadly this is the case here. Just makes me feel powerless
(3)
Report
See 4 more replies
Marcie - if your mother is one of those women who love the abuse and its endless rewards, then I recommend you try this approach.

Reward #1-Your mother loves complaining to you about the abuse, then stop listening to her. Tell her: "I don't want to hear again about how awfully you were treated unless you stop going to your brother and volunteer for more abuse."

Reward #2-Your mother loves to feel like a victim and have others feel sorry for her. You stop telling her what a poor woman she is, and what an assh0le her brother is. She's not a victim. She is in control of her actions.

Reward #3 - She gets to be the center of attention. "I'm being abused here, pay attention to me." Everyone's got their own problems, big or small, but none is more attention grabbing than hers. Gosh, everyone, stop what you're doing and pay attention to this poor soul.

Act nonchalant. Don't give her the attention she's craving. When she starts rehashing the abuse, you walk away.

Remember, your mother is IN CONTROL of her actions. In fact, if you have the nerve, then ask her when she's going back to her brother since she seems to enjoy his company so much.

Maybe, if/when she stops getting the rewards she's looking for, she'll stop getting abused by choice.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Polarbear is spot on. These types of people love attention, and there's no better way to get it than playing the victim. If she starts whining hang up the phone, or leave her presence asap.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter