Follow
Share

My sisters have never been very nice over the years and I have had to step in when mum and dad have been upset because they have been ignored by them. They haven't, in the past, spoken to our parents for years. Dad died and mum was taken in by sister. I couldn't look after mum as I had a mental health problem and was in and out of hospital. Sister then stopped me from seeing mum in the last 3 years of her life, even though I wanted to see mum.


Mum has now died and sister blames me for making mum miserable in the last few years of her life. Sister has cut me off and never wants to speak to me again. Sister has said she wants to 'follow her own path with her own family'. I have nobody else. I'm 65 years old and I don't know what I've done wrong. I've asked my sister but she won't tell me. I want to stay in my own home as I get older but I'm lonely and more so now my sister has cut me off. Years ago I helped mum/dad as much as I could in order to keep them happy and I helped look after/educate and entertain my sisters; children. So, I'm at a loss as to why they have cut me off. I'm struggling to come to terms with this. What has gone wrong do you think?

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
Hey OP. No means no. Does it mean the no is fair? No. Does it mean that it'll change soon or ever? Not necessarily.

I advise you to cultivate peers and others that you see as sort of family. It may not be "family" in the way your sister biologically is, but she has said no to social connection--which you can cultivate otherwise.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report
dynorod Dec 2021
Sister got Covid recently and then all of a sudden she started messaging me as though she had never cut me off. Now she's gone back to 'I want to follow my own path' thing and don't bother me. I feel 'gaslighted' by her as well.

She cut off mum/dad about 10 years ago and I had to be the main caregiver during this time as our parents were so upset and crying a lot. Then she got back in contact when she needed money and her son was taking hard drugs.

Each of us as sisters has stepped up to help mum/dad but younger sister is acting like a martyr and says she doesn't want to communicate ever again. Then out of the blue she opens up dialogue again ( she had Covid) but communication was short lived. It is so confusing.
(2)
Report
Dear dynorod,

I'm sorry you feel so hurt by your sister's actions. Families are so hard. I'm the oldest of four sisters. I too was the main caregiver to my parents. I know it's hard when the lines of communications are not open. But maybe your sister does feel a lot of anger and resentment about being the primary caregiver to your mum in her final years.

If you want you can write her a letter or hopefully your other sisters will help mend the relationships. Take your time and maybe consider talking to a grief counsellor, family therapist or joining a support group or other community groups for support.

I know we all long for family closeness and togetherness but sometimes we cannot achieve that on our own. Give your sister time and maybe she will come around.

Thinking of you.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report
dynorod Dec 2021
No point writing a letter she doesn't read them or reply.
(6)
Report
See 3 more replies
I'm sorry for your loss. We don't get to pick our family but we do get to pick our friends. This is what I would concentrate on -- finding qualify friends.
Helpful Answer (17)
Report

I think it has been a pattern throughout your sister's lives to cut off family when they become inconvenient, it doesn't necessarily have anything to do with something you have done. My sister is a decade older than I am and my reality is that she will possibly not be there for me when I'm in my later years, I am also single and childless. I think the best we can do for ourselves is to plan for the inevitability of the lack of family supports in our old age, you must periodically weigh your desire to remain where you are with your physical, emotional and mental health needs.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report
dynorod Dec 2021
It's so hard to accept that my sister doesn't love or want me except when it suits her
(2)
Report
The past us gone now, and nothing can be done about it. Your Sister has chosen to move on and away from you. There is, quite honestly, nothing to be done about that other than to say it makes you sad, and you hope she will contact you in future. Then I would go on with my own mental health issues and healing. You will form a community around you in that manner, going on and making friends and "family" of a sort that treasures you, and who can identify with you. There are many forms of group therapy in which people can provide emotional support and understanding with one another, a community. Check with your own therapist about opportunities such as this.
Wish your sister goodspeed in getting on with her own life, and get on with yours. Many don't have family. Many have family that is more a trial and a burden than a gift. I wish you the very best moving forward and hope that your new year is a first step toward a productive, happier life for yourself.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report

"It's so hard to accept that my sister doesn't love or want me except when it suits her"

Your sister is a user. When she needs something from you, she will be all lovey. It's not you. You have to realize this is her and not let yourself get sucked in. Maybe the reason she took Mom in was because she may get something out of caring for her.

You are now 65 with your own health problems. Every cent you have you will need for YOUR future. YOU are responsible for that future. Don't expect someone to care for you. You need to plan for when u get older.
Helpful Answer (12)
Report
dynorod Dec 2021
That strikes a note! Sister contacted me after mum died because apparently I'm the executor of mums will. Other sister reckons sister has been trying to forge my signature but I dismissed this as just catiness on my other sister's part. Sister has been trying to control the probate. What a mess!
(4)
Report
See 2 more replies
Hi! It’s worse when it’s your own daughter. If you can’t understand, and they won’t explain, you really do have to let it go. Perhaps the reason they won’t explain is because they know it doesn’t stand up. Work hard on making your own life as enjoyable as you can. By the way, it was Greta Garbo who ‘wanted to be alone’. Mae West was more ‘come up and see me sometime’. Sis does the Greta Garbo, you need to do the Mae West!
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Seems you never should have steeped into the dynamics between your sisters and your parents. That was their relationship to figure out and should not have included you trying to step in. Send your sister an apology for doing so and then accept her choice to live as she wishes. You really don’t need or want a relationship with someone who doesn’t feel the same. Time to build a new circle of people from social groups, senior centers, volunteering, and church. I wish you peace as you move forward
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
dynorod Dec 2021
Already apologised numerous times. Sister wouldn't let me anywhere near mum in her final years. She also wouldn't let my other sister near mum. Mum was also cut off by sister to all her other relations e.g her cousins or siblings ( my aunt/uncle)
(4)
Report
See 1 more reply
You have no way of knowing whether this sister will or won't read a letter you write to her. So I'd go ahead and write her a letter opening up my heart and spilling out my thoughts onto paper. Then post the letter and go about your life. Whether she reads it or not is out of your hands. Once you put it in the mailbox, then you've taken the last step towards fixing what appears to be a broken relationship.

You may have not done enough for your parents in their final days, in your sister's opinion, and now she's angry with you. You can't change another person's opinion of you, that's a fact. But you CAN choose to know that you did what you could do for your parents, and then move on with your own life.

I will be 65 years old in July and I have no siblings but one half-sister I met in 2000 (long story) who I barely keep in touch with. We on a public forum cannot possibly know what has gone wrong in your life with your sister; you yourself may have an inkling but if not, try to stop dwelling on it. You've apologized and sent flowers, so now the ball is in HER court, should she decide to play once more.

If not, try to forge ahead with your own life which should not be contingent on what your sister does or does not do. Sign up with an online dating service and go out and have some FUN! In many ways, life begins at 65 so go figure out how to make YOU happy!

Wishing you the best of luck carving out your own life now~!
Helpful Answer (17)
Report

Hi,it happens but we find a way to Agee to disagree about anything, my faith has made me strong to overlook misunderstandings with my sibs,I let it go and one day things did turn around..I have to live and let live😃.Meantime keep yourself busy by helping someone else it's rewarding.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
imout01 Jan 2022
Or help yourself. That can be rewarding, too, if you feel you’ve spent time, wasting your life with a narcissistic family. Pick up a hobby or long lost interest, that provides you with psychological and emotional income.
(8)
Report
If this treatment from your siblings has been going on for years it is not going to change and it may not even have anything concrete to do with you; you have simply become a 'scapegoat'. It's terribly sad to be aging and feel family has disintegrated but sounds like this has been a fractured family for a long time. Try to give yourself a break, stop expecting sib(s) to ever explain 'why' (because they probably don't even know or wouldn't/couldn't see they've been mean/cruel toward you.) You did what you could when your parents were alive, toward other relatives; now is the time to Emancipate yourself and find ways to make your remaining years as good as possible, You may grieve the loss of a Sense of family, but if you are being honest these relatives have not been true family for a long time. It is healthy to accept that reality, mourn the loss of your hopes, release them with love, and live your life on your terms; find real friends/companions, do things that are meaningful to you. Expand your concept of 'family' beyond blood relations.
Helpful Answer (20)
Report
marymary2 Jan 2022
Yes on everything you say. If anything we in similar situations need to grieve that loss of a dream of a loving family (because it was never true).
(1)
Report
So sorry you are experiencing this. Time to develop friendships with others that are kind to you. Sometimes these friends can become the family you always desired.
Helpful Answer (16)
Report
marymary2 Mar 2022
True, but so hard when you're a senior yourself. Most people of the baby boomer generation already have spouses, children, grandchildren and friends galore. Maybe even their lifelong communities. For those of us who moved frequently are to far flung places as children and then again as adults due to economic necessity, most people aren't open to adding to their group of intimates, especially if you are a childless single woman. You can volunteer endlessly, join groups, etc. When others' lives are already full, you're out of luck.
(0)
Report
My sister and I are no longer on speaking terms since my mother was living with me. She was with me for 3 months and they wanted me to care to her and pay for her way. I put my foot down and my sister picked up my mother and I decided not to talk to my sister from that point on. She has always been deceptive and a narcissistic, and I was expected to do as I’m told and not question the abuse.

Your sister sounds like a narcissist and I think you should read up on it. Most of these traits she learned from my mother, and they both are proud of being ruthless to others. My personality is more empathetic and they look at that as a sign of weakness. Be true to yourself, stay kind and step back. My mother is still living but she has probably changed her will and removed me from everything. My mother enjoys the control of both my sister and I and she’ll try to have us turn on each other. It’s her way of getting attention.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report
imout01 Jan 2022
Same.
(3)
Report
See 2 more replies
As others have advised, don't rely on your sister(s) for your social life. Look for other people who need your talents and who share your interests.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
wonolancet Jan 2022
Great answer RedVanAnnie!! Get involved with folks who appreciate you!!
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
Dynorod, I just picked up on one of your replies: if you are indeed an executor - even if only a joint executor with your other sister - of your mother's will then you need to do something about it. The will can't be carried out without your input, and even if you're not interested in the will's contents you have a legal duty to perform. Find out!
Helpful Answer (9)
Report
MargaretMcKen Jan 2022
An executor appointed in a will can renounce, they aren't forced to take up the position after the testator's death. Even more so after their own death!
(1)
Report
This is sad, because you have done all you could do caring for your mother. Your sister is one selfish lady which will come back to her full fold down the road. Also, I find people cannot deal with the reality of a sick and dying parents so take these strange life paths to avoid the obvious. Your sister looks at your age and sees her own mortality in the mirror and realizes it is coming. So, she is running. You hang in there and do the best you can as you are miles ahead of her and have done nothing wrong! You, my dear have my ultimate "RESPECT"!!
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Im 49 and my brother is a narcissist and blames me for everything although hes the black sheep of the family. Im the doting daughter. We didnt talk for two yrs but he reached out passively and of course because he wants me involved financially. I got parents a condo and hes a free bird after he committed but pulled out. Manipulative. Always. Useless and miserable hvg them around so it doesn’t matter if you dont talk to them.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Sounds like sis has some guilt problems. You don't point fingers unless you're trying to take the light off of yourself. People are only as miserable as they allow themselves to be. If sister watched after Mum, then maybe mum was miserable because sister cut everyone off.
You reach out and find some good friends, and enjoy your life. It sounds like sis is the one with the problem. Good people don't bite and criticize others unless they are self centered themselves.
You've done all you could. You have nothing to feel guilty about unless you allow sis to manipulate you. My hats off to you. Live your life.
As we age, we should become wiser. I have discovered that I can't change other people. Stop apologizing. According to the bible, you've done all that's required of you in God's eyes and to keep doing it is to allow yourself to be manipulated.
This is a new chapter. Close that chapter and turn the page. What is it they say, "You can pick your friends but you can't pick your family?" By the time a person gets over 50, they either choose to change or they don't. Not your problem if they don't.
Step into your new chapter guilt free and enjoy your life. God says in Jeremiah, "I know the plans I have for you; to give you a hope and a future, to prosper and not to harm you". Find your purpose and pursue it.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
Aggravated Jan 2022
We are in the age of technology, make friends online that can be changed over to friends that you see. As someone who has had this same sort of problem with my immediate family, I have started spending more time with friends and cousins who enjoy my company and like to spend time with me, We all make sure that we are negative with Covid and just make sure that we wear masks while out in the public period.

Life is much too short to deal with other people's problems, as all way stay safe and don't give out personal information or money. Also if you can do it safely, volunteer as my friend has done this as his mom passed away recently. He has a new GF and also is getting out more and enjoying life.

This month I turn 56 and I'm going out and enjoying life and taking it one day at a time.
(5)
Report
See 2 more replies
Very confusing but the fact remains that all of your siblings have been estranged from one another over the years. You cannot control another person and it seems you have done everything possible to get back into your youngest sisters graces. I suspect over time, when she "needs" you she will reach out again as she did when she had Covid. One never knows what's going on in another's mind or life - and it appears your sister has issues of her own. Let the reconciliation go, pray for the best possible outcome, and move on. Can you re-establish a bond with your other sister? Can you volunteer where you may be helpful and meet others who can enrich your life? Join a church group? Reach out to old friends through Facebook? Join a travel club? Anything to create a new supportive network of people.
The missing piece to the puzzle is the fact that you say you are the Executor of your Mom's "estate". If that is the case, I urge you to contact a good attorney to represent your interests ASAP, as it appears this may be a motivating factor in why your sister may be making it look like you are a disinterested party. If you are the Executor, it is certainly your legal right to know and carry out your mothers final wishes. I wish you the best of luck on your journey.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
WhippinPost50 Apr 2022
Oh wow. What a thoughtful, insightful & important contribution you’ve made! I wish I pick your brain a bit more. She WILL go for guardianship, there is an annuities account with the majority of all family money in it. They brother & (evil) sister are hiding that it even exists! As DPOAs I am not executor until my father dies by then it could be drained & the trust I’m executor of emptied by then. I’m disabled & can’t afford an attorney & they know it. My future would seriously be changed in a few years when my dad with severe dementia passes. The stack of savings bonds are not recorded anywhere! I just cannot let evil walk away with my inheritance while being painted a “disinterested party”… It sounds like you have a grasp on how this all works! Since my dad has never been “not” seriously disabled his words lol even their “iron clad” DPOA could easily be challenged by me but I don’t know what to do first! I may have to file a elder financial abuse type of inquiry to get the data. Proving their concealing the majority of my parents assets is a pretty big lie to uncover.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
Trust me when I tell you you are better off because it sounds like your sister has mental health issues herself. I am in the same boat. In my case I was the product of rape, we lived with the father of the older sibling. The older sibling could not be bothered so I got stuck with the care giving until our mother became in her 90's, now realizing she may not have much time left has coerced our mother with abuse into handing over total control now pushing to take bank accounts and the house. I did nothing but show kindness to this 1/2 sibling even though her and her husband also subjected me to abuse when I was younger. I gave our mother above average care and she flourished, now there is neglect and abuse and our mother has very quickly deteriorated. Our mother acts like I'm to blame for the neglect and abuse the other daughter is doing to her. I'm telling you this to let you know do not beat yourself up wondering. My 1/2 sibling blamed me for her father's death and he died when a heart aneurysm burst. When our mother dies she'll do the same nasty attitude. My point being there is an issue with them, not you but them and I do not regret the love and care I provided our mother, however I think there always has been mental illness of both our mother and the 1/2 sibling. They basically used me and seeing how they use people, have no remorse empathy or conscience for how they mistreat people clearly indicates to me that they both have something seriously wrong mental health wise. So as I said do not waste your time wondering, she is not worth the effort, focus on the positive people in your life and move forward. It may not seem like it now but you will find a huge weight lifted off your shoulders.
Helpful Answer (12)
Report

That's so confusing and hard Dynorod. It seems pretty clear from last sentence of first para and first sentence of second paragraph-you were prevented from seeing your Mom for the last three years of her life and now your sister blames you for making your mother miserable???? Hard to see any logic in that whatsoever.

I agree with those who say you're being scapegoated for decisions sister has already made and also with those who point out the necessity of a lawyer to help you execute or co-execute the will.

And yes while it's hard move on and live your own life-your sister who seems quite capricious and changing in her views is not to be relied on, clearly.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

I think you now what the issues are between you and your sister. It most likely is simply that there never was a connection. I had the same situation with a sister. She passed almost ten years ago. We just never liked each other and we dealt with it and moved on. If you worry about being lonely, you will have to do something for yourself. Volunteer work, part time job, learn something new. I learned how to dance at age 60. Dozens of new friends. Learned how to ride horses with some of those friends who were ranchers. Find something you will like. It may be activities at a local senior center. The point is to put yourself in contact with others and some will turn out to be friends. Some won't. But your efforts to mend and bond with your sister sounds like it will only end in more negative results. Sometimes, family isn't just biological or blood. Sometimes when it's not...it's the best.
Helpful Answer (13)
Report
missfits Jan 2022
Thanks for posting this. I’ve never heard anyone say that they just didn’t like their siblings. I felt that way for a long time and now that I don’t talk to my sister and all the drama she used to cause is gone…I am a lot happier. It’s comforting to know that you can move on from bad family members.
(3)
Report
Family is a gift no one can buy. Dysfunctional families mean some members were hurt and decided to leave, such as from divorced parents. Perhaps professional help will get you through difficulties so you may move on to volunteer and make new friends.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

You can't change anyone, but YOU can change how you react to someone. Look at it this way - would you put up with this type of behaviour from a friend? Of course you wouldn't, so why should a family member be any different. You need to empower yourself to stop seeking a relationship with your sister just because she is a "relative", SET BOUNDARIES, and stick to it. Had to do the same with my younger sister. Her jealousy of me and my family (because she is the black sheep of the family) manifested itself into ugliness to the point I had to shut that door 3 years ago - coincidentally after my Dad passed away from complications of Alzheimers. Fortunately, my parents had wills, trusts and POAs in place and I can take care of everything for my Mother's sake without any help from my sister. You can't fix a broken relationship - you need to move on now and develop healthier relationships with friends. Remember - NO ONE can mistreat you unless YOU allow it. Peace be with you.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

Why don't you find a good place to volunteer a few hours a week and develop some meaningful friendships there and you will be able to live your life without the sorrow of your lack of family relations. You will find happiness in service to others.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

This happens far too often and for reasons no one knows about or has the means to understand. If you have made every attempt and nothing changes, then make up your mind to SEVER ALL TIES - it is scary being alone but it is far better than to pray you will have help and you never will and there is no relationship. I have gone through this and am totally alone at age 88 and disabled. It is very hard but there are times in life severing all ties opens other doors to a new future. First of all, try to consult the advice of an eldercare attorney as to the best options for YOU to prepare for YOUR advancing age and care. Make sure l00% of all your affairs are in perfect order at all times. Try to find someone you trust to be a Power of Attorney and who would step up to the plate. It is a big undertaking but I have not a soul in the world. I have everything in perfect order and take care of myself l00% - whether you can or cannot do this, I don't know but start with an eldercare attorney who will advise you what you need to do for your future. You will finally have some peace which you do not have now. Walk forward and never look back - it will destroy you if you keep holding on to "nothing".
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
Davenport Jan 2022
And check out the book "But It's Family!"--it's a step-by-step how-to emotionally break from unsupportive and mean/dysfunctional family members.
(2)
Report
Look back at your communications to your sister. Certainly any “sent” emails or retained texts may hold the answer. Don’t ask her further “closure” information - she has asked for no relationship and grant her that peace.

Your question suggests that you didn’t have a consistently good time with your siblings. You also indicate that your caretaking sister limited interaction and visitors with your mother.

After my parents passed, relationships with some of my siblings have changed completely. Initially it stung, but in the big picture, it was for the best.

Consider the falling out a blessing. You are also free to choose your own path.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Maybe your sister sees that your getting older and lonely and doesn’t want to get involved.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Follow the money.

Disclaimer:
Do not follow this advice if it does not apply to you or your family's circumstances. imo.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

This post brings up a personal situation of my own. I will just post the reality of what has happened in my life and hopefully others can see another perspective of this type of thing.
I have a sister, 2 years younger than me. Most of her adult life she has been a raging alcoholic. Certainly has mental health issues. She has had a pattern of getting drunk and calling a member of the family to rage, scream, call names, make false accusations. Every one of us has been the victim of her tirades many times, she just makes the rounds. We are SO sick of this nastiness. Her birthday is the same as our dad, and on his last birthday, before he died, he was her victim. She called him over and over, screaming, cussing, yelling at him. He called me and said, "I don't know what to do. She won't stop." I told him not to answer any calls from her the rest of the day. My mom & stepdad were her targets many times, but she has no idea why they wrote her off. I said to her in the last year, that it was because of all the times she had called them and cussed them out while drunk. She DOES NOT get the fact that she is the problem.
On July 17, 2020 I gave her notice that if she ever did it again, I would block her number and never have anything to do with her again. The few times we have talked in the past few years since I have taken on caring for our mother who has dementia, this ick of a sister has brought up what she wants from mom's belongings when mom dies. I use mom's money to take care of mom's needs, but this ick accuses me of being greedy.
She has absolutely NO awareness that she has done anything wrong. She can't understand at all why her family treats her so bad. Such a narcissist.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter